Best Pizza in New Braunfels

Savor the flavors of handcrafted pizzas made with passion

We Cater All Events

😍 Mattenga's love catering! Catering for your special occasion is always a privilege for us. Whether a small intimate gathering or a huge corporate function, we're happy to fill every celebration with our excellent food and service. Let us serve you with great memories! Check out the link below to book your catering with us today

Request A Catering Quote

About Mattenga's Pizzeria 46 HW New Braunfels

At Mattenga's Pizzeria, we offer delicious, handcrafted pizzas made with fresh, high-quality ingredients. Our pizzas are perfect for a casual meal or a special occasion. We also have a variety of other menu items, including salads, pasta, and sandwiches. We offer dine-in and take-out service, and our friendly staff is always happy to help you choose the perfect meal. Come see us today for a taste of our delicious pizza!

See our most popular items

Here’s a sneak peek of the items our customers can’t stop talking about

Only Fresh Ingredients

Mattenga's Pizzeria uses only the freshest, highest-quality ingredients in our pizzas. Our dough is made from scratch every day, and our sauce is simmered for hours to bring out the maximum flavor. We use only the finest meats and cheeses, and our vegetables are always crisp and fresh. When you order a pizza from Mattenga's, you can be sure that you're getting a delicious, made-from-scratch meal that's bursting with flavor.

Made With Love

At Mattenga's Pizzeria, we believe that food is love. That's why we take the time to make each and every pizza with care and attention to detail. We use only the freshest ingredients, and we cook our pizzas in a wood-fired oven to give them that delicious, authentic flavor. When you order a pizza from Mattenga's, you can be sure that you're getting a meal that's made with love. We know that you'll love our pizza as much as we love making it.

What our customers are saying

Check out our most recent reviews!

Fast and fantastic tasting pizza. We have several choices for good quality pizza near us but our go to is Mattenga's pizza. We have never been let down. Our favorite crust is the thin crust but both are excellent. Top quality toppings with great flavors. Add their fresh basil. Mmm mmm. You will not be disappointed.

Wade Lind

This is probably best as a take-out only place. We tried this for the first time last night and agree that the pizza was good, maybe even some of the better pie in town, but they’re not set up for dine-in or for hosting guests. *Three tables *no way to get water or refill a drink (Ice is behind the counter and requires the checker to put down her phone to refill) *full 30-minute wait for pizza *Salad (brought in prepackaged plastic box for twice the price of any other place in town) at the same time the pizza box was dropped on the table. (Salad was also not made as ordered.) *Styrofoam plates and plastic silverware rounded out our experience. Again, not an issue if you take out, but as a patron, it’s not a great experience. Listening to the checker chat on the company phone and/or play on her phone while someone is waiting to ask for a refill put a bad taste in our mouths. Good pizza, below average dining experience

Kristan R

Having traveled all over the US, Mattenga's is one of the best pizzas we've had! Outstanding customer service is just a bonus and if you have the opportunity to be served by Parker, you'll know! He's not only an obvious hustler in the kitchen but is quick to serve you as a customer! Can't recommend enough if you're in the area!

Doran Eichenberg

Sunday around 5:30 pm. The young lady in the front was delightful and very professional. She was amazing with every customer that came in. Articulated herself very well. She was the reason for the experience being so great!! Even said bye when she left and got off of work. Pizza was solid Breadsticks pretty good. Few things to tighten up operational but overall solid. Love that its a Christian based business in town.

Raymond Pownall

The pizza was delish. Got the 14in. Pepperoni. Fed 3 of us with pieces to spare. Crust was lite and had some texture. Price was also good. Smiling staff even though they were super busy with in store and phone orders. I'll go back.